Good Products Can Become Invisible When AI Builds the Shortlist
Sannah Vinding returns to The Kula Ring five years after her first appearance, now the author of Visible or Invisible. She has watched well-engineered products miss the shortlist because buyers couldn’t find them, and AI-assisted research makes that more likely. Engineers now research, compare and shortlist before they speak to a supplier, so a manufacturer with missing or inconsistent product information never learns it had a chance to quote. Sannah walks through the five foundations in her book, explains why accurate product information is the hardest to get right, and recommends starting with a small pilot. She also shares a sales rep’s story that shows why buyers still need a person to talk to.
Good Products Can Become Invisible When AI Builds the Shortlist Transcript:
Jeff White: Welcome to The Kula Ring, a podcast for manufacturing marketers brought to you by Kula Partners. My name is Jeff White, and joining me today is Carman Pirie. Carman, how you doing, sir?
Carman Pirie: I am delighted to be here, Jeff, and excited for today’s conversation once again.
Jeff White: It’s always exciting when a previous guest of ours comes back to tell us what they’ve been working on. And in this case, our guest was last on the show five years ago. So that, that speaks to the longevity of the podcast. It went even back further than that, but also just the amazing things that some of our guests have been working on.
Carman Pirie: And to be fair to her, I’m sure she worked on a number of things in those five years.
Jeff White: She waited to do the podcast again. That’s how I’m choosing to remember it.
Carman Pirie: No, that’s fair. Okay. Yeah. All right.
Jeff White: But not only that, but our guest is coming to us having recently authored a book.
Carman Pirie: Yeah fresh off of that, which is it’s gotta be it’s just a huge accomplishment, frankly. And ch- chatting with an author who’s just gotten through it you can just hear the relief in their voice the entire time.
Jeff White: Everything else seems easy for a little while maybe.
Carman Pirie: Exactly. Exactly.
Jeff White: So joining us today for the second time is Sannah Vinding. Sannah is an author of a new book called “Visible or Invisible.” Welcome to the Kula Ring, Sannah.
Sannah Vinding: Thank you so much. I’m happy to be here. And I have my book right here, right? Because I don’t think you have it yet, but here it is.
Jeff White: Unfortunately it’s an audio-only podcast, but we will certainly be linking people can pick it up, and we’ll include an image of it in the in the show notes for sure.
Sannah Vinding: Nice
Carman Pirie: Yeah and so we can rest assured everyone, the “Visible or Invisible” book is indeed visible.
Sannah Vinding: It is.
Jeff White: it’s not the emperor’s new book. Yeah.
Carman Pirie: Sannah please, reintroduce our listeners to you, if you would, and tell us about the book, please.
Sannah Vinding: So as you just said I’m Sannah. So I’m a mechanical engineer, that’s my background, and I spent my career across product management, product marketing, and within lighting, hearing technology, then electronics components, that’s where we met five years ago and then also in semiconductors.
So a lot of experience of what’s happening in the industry. And I just wrote the book, and what you said called Visible or Invisible, and it’s one that is just highlighting the importance that you need to lean into to AI within this electronics industry. Because right now how engineers, or you or me — it’s changing the habit and how we look for solutions.
So this book is actually addressing it to say you need to be aware of how engineers are looking for solutions, and if you don’t show up here you won’t get that call. You will actually not know that you had an opportunity to be able to quote or to be a part of a bigger project here.
Jeff White: I think, many of the listeners to this podcast tend to be marketers who would love to know how engineers are thinking and how they’re using tools in order to find them and their company’s solutions. So if you wouldn’t mind, dive into that a little bit. How have you found engineers to be leveraging these ever-evolving tool sets?
Sannah Vinding: So I always, and I have that as in the book as well, I’m like, looked at myself as an engineer, and maybe I didn’t build a product, but I needed new tires for my car. So instead of calling I asked AI to say, “ I need new tires. What should I look for? Give me low price, mid price, high price,” ’cause I wanted my selection.
It came back. I did Google and goes there and saying, “Okay, is it correct what it’s giving me a recommendation,” right? You’d wanna have that touch, and then again, delete Google. But did my research, did my critical thinking. But I went through, selecting it, finding who should install them, all that without talking to anyone, right?
I just used the tools that I had so I could find the best solution that I wanted. I paid for them, and when I walked in to that to that place, that was the first time I talked to a human being. They did not do anything, right? But everything around them the brand for the car of course they had published what needed to be out there, what they recommended of which tire it should be.
The place I went to also had said, “We are the fastest,” so you don’t… just book it, pay for the tires, and show up. So there was a lot of things there that just connected. So looking at how I am using it, and others for hope- hopefully as well, is just going to interfere of how we interact, so that’s also how an engineer, right?
They will sit, research, look up in different tools, and that’s different, right? There is where you can search on lead times, right? There’s SAAS software as well that combine everything. If you build your PCB print there’s software there. So there’s more intelligence coming in different ways and offering that will be that you won’t speak to a person right there.
So we just… you have to address that if you wanna show up, if you’re a manufacturer or you’re distributor you have to be sure that you’re thinking about this piece. And I think you also… Didn’t you have a stat that came out of how long… What was the percentage? I have it right here. 82% shortlist before somebody talk to a supplier. So I think that, that should wake up the whole electronics industry.
Carman Pirie: Yeah it was. There was a lot that you just said there, Sannah, that was interesting to me, but what jumped out was just how much of what you just said was possible before anybody, any of us had ever heard about ChatGPT or Claude. Yes, the AI discoverability is adding another dimension to it, but a lot of what you just said that has been the reality for a while. Do you feel like it’s been a conveniently ignored reality for a lot of manufacturers?
Jeff White: Or maybe just too difficult to do the layering and all the checks?
Sannah Vinding: Yeah but you have all the questions, right? Maybe they already added that to their website. But if you put the AI as a top layer it’s just a new filtering or new tool for you to get more efficient, right? I’m also, like, taking picture of my dishwasher saying, “What’s going on here?”
“The gasket is wrong,” right? “What’s happening?” And it can jump directly and give me a link to a YouTube video showing how to replace it by that second in the video. I don’t think Google could do that a few years ago. Maybe they can do it now ’cause they also have Gemini, right?
They have AI. But I think it’s how you look up information, search for information, validate information. It gives you… It’s just another dimension, just as you said, right? It’s giving you another dimension. And you n- and you need to… You can have prepped everything to say, “Yes, we are doing all our SEO,” right?
“We will show up,” “on Google.” But with AI, if you’re using cloud, if it’s ChatGPT, if you’re using a SaaS software, something that’s built on anything of this, right? It’s just a, it’s a new dimension, and nobody knows what’s in it, right? To say, “Oh, they are writing this,” right? “I need to then search, so show up for that.”
Carman Pirie: Yes, and I should note that in suggesting that it was somewhat that a lot of that reality had been something that we’d already been living for a while now, in no way was I trying to minimize the additional complexity that AI brings to it, because of course it truly does, and I think that’s what marketers are really living right now is…
Even little things like, okay, so you’re like, “Oh, it’s just another channel. It’s gonna be another area of discovery.” Sure, and some of your lead attribution may show that some of those leads are showing up via ChatGPT or via Claude or what have you. But then, of course, the smarter marketers are realizing that it’s also changing their direct traffic numbers.
Like there’s a percentage of AI that shows up as direct traffic after somebody does the research in an app and then copy and paste the URL or what have you. There’s more to it, and it’s making it messier for marketers, isn’t it?
Sannah Vinding: Yeah. Yeah it is. It is. And then everybody has an opinion, right? How to create marketing, so you still have to fight that part. But it does. I think it’s good to say just it’s… I don’t think it’s The Matrix, right? But it’s just a new level that you need to be aware of and have a strategy for.
Carman Pirie: And conveniently, you mentioned about the SEO side of the equation, and one of – that’s been one of the debates I found raging in this space is to what extent is generative engine optimization and SEO the same thing? I suppose somewhat connected to that is some people are pouring some pretty cold water on the idea that you can even call the shots in generative engine optimization, saying some of the things that are being held up as best practice actually don’t don’t achieve any particular outcomes.
Where do you land on that? Is good SEO good GEO? Is it yes, and? Is it, “Ah, it’s a bit different, but…” Talk to us.
Sannah Vinding: So SEO is not dead. Come on. It’s still there, it’s still strong. That’s how I see it. But it, now it’s just, it’s one component, right? You need the GEO as well. And again, how you find and search for how to create these answers that you know your customers are looking for you need to be close to your customers.
I think that’s one thing. Because if you have that direct communication, you know what they’re looking for. You know what’s, what will benefit them, what will that make that engineer to shine, what’s happening. Is it thermal, right? What’s happening when they’re designing something? And then again, there’s a lot of SAAS companies out there that say, “Oh, we know,” right?
“We can give you all the insight here.” I don’t think you know all the insights. That’s why it’s better to go directly to your customers or to your sales force or the sales team that you have and customer service and get that kind of insight. So it’s much more important now to have the voice of the customer than ever, because having that information together with your SEO now you can actually build and scale in a whole new world
Jeff White: As part of your, the “Visible or Invisible” book that you wrote, you also produced a bit of a framework for how to think about this. It talks about five different connected foundations to help make all of that visible to- Yeah … potential prospects, to potential customers, existing customers, and all of that.
Can you talk us through a little bit about what you found there and how those different components interact and why they’re important?
Sannah Vinding: Yeah, so it’s built on five pillars if you wanna say that, right? So it’s product truth, it’s governance knowledge, it’s signal quality, and it’s workflow readiness, and then human trust. And the human trust is important here. We don’t just give everything to AI. So how I see it is that you build like your knowledge within the company.
So with the product truth, this is, creating your specs that they’re available. Make sure that you have the data sheet, have the distributor listing, right? What’s the lead time? All that is connecting. But of course, what you create into this knowledge center, if you wanna say it like that, you have to be sure that you have that human eye on it, that it’s been validated because you don’t want later finding out that you’re showing one lead time and the distributor’s showing something else, or you have version five of your data sheet and the distributor’s still showing version three.
So there’s a lot of making sure that you have that information so it’s that product truth, right? And then making sure that when you communicate out, when you have new product introductions or you just have updates on your product portfolio, that you share from this knowledge base. Another one is the governance knowledge, right?
You need to be sure that the expertise is there. So is it the engineers? Is it the FAE? They sit with a lot of information. So making sure that you actually extract that information, if you interview them, if they have any video where you can take that what they know, not… You’re not removing them.
You still need them. They’re so important. But if they always ask every week “Oh, give me a cross for product X and Y,” and they’ve been asked about that all the time, why not take that one and saying, “Okay, let’s put that into the product knowledge.” So making sure that you have that knowledge. And again, every of these you need that human touch on it so that you know it’s been validated.
Signal quality. This is actually to know which of the buyers, the activity, right? What’s happening. So that could be if you have a website and there’s any files they download. I’m not saying you have to have something gated ’cause that is not going to help you right now. It has to be ungated, so it’s open.
But it could be an ECAD file, right? It could be something that you see that you have to, to… You have to sign up to be able to download these kind of files. So that could be a signal of saying, “Okay, this is happening.” And then again going into this knowledge center that sales and also FAE can look at.
Carman Pirie: You mentioned the signal quality. I think it is important for manufacturers to know that they maybe can play a bit of a different game there, and you highlighted it, right? There are some pieces of content that you can still ask for contact information in exchange for getting it.
Jeff White: There’s nowhere else to get it.
Carman Pirie: Yeah. I appreciate that kind of in content marketing writ large, the guidance is generally un-gate. But it’s one of those times I think when manufacturers in certain categories and in certain parts of their product information, they can zig while the rest of the content marketers zag.
And so I was excited to hear you bring that up, Sannah. But didn’t mean to interrupt your flow ’cause two more pillars.
Sannah Vinding: The next one is the work- workflow readiness. So this is also have clear owners and handoff before you put it in your knowledge center, if you wanna call it that, or before you hand it over to AI. So you need to know, what are the steps, right?
Have that workflow to say, “Yes, this is the data sheet version five. Now we are adding it in here. We have the human eyes on it. This is what goes in.” And then the fifth one, I even though I said human at every one there’s also the human trust here. Because you can look up so much, right?
But there’s still the one where you wanna talk to a person. And just back to personal again, right? If I need to book an appointment at my doctor or something, and I know it’s not within the electronics industry here, sometimes I do wanna talk to a person instead of having that bot on the on the website or on the phone.
So the human trust is going to be a value add for everyone within this industry. You just need to know when you’re opening it up to say, “Okay, you wanna talk to somebody,” but then you need to be fast here.
Jeff White: Do you think that, The moment when the human comes into that relationship is changing, that it’s getting, further into that shortlisting process or is it becoming more important and more relevant earlier where people are trying to validate the findings?
Sannah Vinding: Oh, I love this because this is like saying it depends, right?
Jeff White: Ah, the consultant’s answer.
Sannah Vinding: Oh, yeah, the consultant. No so how I see it, right? Because if you look on the other side, right? How do you build… If you’re like sales or a manufacturing rep or just the sales the account manager, how do you build that relationship with your customer and your future customers?
That is, I believe you… Of course you need to have all this available so they can find you, so you are visible. But being, having that human touch and having that business relationship is so important, and how do you build that? That is of showing up when they need you, or if and saying, “Oh, I know, thermal is a challenge right now if you build if you develop small devices. We have this product, or we have this case study, or we have this really great value add that I can share or I can send to them somehow,” right? To show the value. That’s a good way of building it. It could also be, which is a little bit the opposite, right?
You have a customer where they can’t… Maybe they have a competitor’s part number and they call you and saying, “Oh, I can’t get it,” right? “Production’s down. What do I do?” And then you save them, right? Saying, “We have the product. This is it,” so they remember you based on this. So there’s different ways of that human trust or that human interaction.
You can’t plan and saying, “Oh, I want it to be step two,” right? Because the buyer’s journey is just so complex now that you need to… The more you have everything in that knowledge center, the better you are setting up for success for your sales team, for the manufacturing reps, but also for that customer looking in, of course depending on how many of the doors you open up so they can look into to this like knowledge center.
So I don’t think you can say it will be earlier, it will be late. You can just see right now that it takes longer, right? To somebody say, “Okay, I wanna talk, I, now I need somebody to talk to.” But you can prepare in a much better way.
Carman Pirie: I think, if I hooked on that idea a little bit and, it seems to me some of what we’re seeing in the… you mentioned the Industrial Buyer Pulse research earlier, and some of what we’re seeing in that, I think, is a lack of willingness to get some information from a person.
Almost like the digital expectations have evolved to a point where I think what the salespeople need to worry about is not will they call me to buy. They will call you to buy. It’s but they won’t call you to not buy, if that makes sense. You’ll actually get punted off the shortlist because you didn’t have information digitally available that maybe only two years ago, that p- same prospect would’ve been quite content to call you to get that information.
But so I do think that is one of the changes that we’re seeing, if I’m trying to connect what you’re saying Sannah, to what we’re seeing in the research. Does that make sense?
Sannah Vinding: That makes sense. I had a conversation a few weeks ago with a manufacturing rep that said that he had a call from an engineer saying, “ This product I specced in, six months ago it’s not in stock. What do I do?” And he was like, “You should have called me six months ago, right?
Where I could have been much better help to solve this, and we could have looked across, right, crosses, or we could have down specced it or up, options there, right? Now, it’s already on that bill of material. Everything has been approved. It’s going to take much longer to get out of it.” So there’s some mindset here as well, right?
That even though you can sit behind your computer, you don’t need to talk to anyone, but you need to look further out and saying, “Okay, could there be any trouble?” So maybe there’s also some educational here, right? For the engineers or for the procurement team to say, “Yeah, even though it shows up in the systems, there is this human touch”.
To say, “Make sure,” right? “When you look ahead that actually everything is what it is.” Because somebody could swap up and buy, everything that’s in stock, right? That maybe there was in stock for six months ago.
Carman Pirie: I’ve, I love how you’ve introduced this kind of like this, all this self-service thing doesn’t always work out. Like this, that was a fascinating example. Like you can, ’cause you can see it happening.
Jeff White: And you also have to wonder how do as a manufacturer, how do you guard against the engineer not asking the question when they found out, and how much of that sort of stock or distributor volatility, could play into the matrix of of your AI-generated shortlist. Not just part quality…
Sannah Vinding: But it’s back to education, right? I think to understand the full circle here, right? So also, so when manufacturers are manufacturing talk to their customers. Explain that to them as well. Bring us in earlier and that, that can be beneficial. It can be that value add.
So changing a little bit of the behavior, which is not easy, right? ’Cause nobody wants to change. So now we’re like, “Oh, I don’t need to talk to anyone. I can just buy the tires,” and then do it that way, right? So it’s, I think it’s about education here.
Carman Pirie: I love the the thought experiment that’s jumping around in my mind is that, we can all… we’ve all encountered building out some sort of digital experience where really what sales wants you to do is put a great big form on the page with a phone number that says, “Please call me now to buy the stuff.” And of course, and we fight against it and you say no, that’s not kinda what you can do.” But, what I’m imagining is that there actually is an instance right here in that workflow, in that example that you showed –showed in an audio podcast, I appreciate that.
And that example that you illustrated that we, there, there could’ve been a more thoughtful, like almost huh, why it might be a good idea to call us now. You could almost be really soft about it and genuine. We have found people doing their own research may get further down a bill of materials than they should without checking with us first.
Probably why you should speak to one of our experts. Here’s how to do it. And it could be, it’d be so soft and helpful and a killer sales move at the same time. That would be really cool.
Jeff White: Could it work against you?
Carman Pirie: I don’t know.
Jeff White: Oh my goodness, they, it, they’re so unsure of their supply chain that they want us to call for every part.
Carman Pirie: I don’t know. I think people expecting something like this, doing this kind of research you know what? Yeah. They understand that there’s supply chain volatility and component selection. To our client who works in medical device components, this podcast wasn’t exactly for you, but it seems like it’s turning out to be, so.
Jeff White: All about that.
Carman Pirie: Yeah. That’s an interesting little nuance.
When you think about those five foundational pillars, Sannah, what’s the hardest one for manufacturers to really wrap their head around? What do you, what one do you think they have the most difficulty with?
Sannah Vinding: I think it’s to organize that product truth. To make sure you have the data sheet, if it’s within a parametric search as well with that information. Quality, right? Having all that information structured. Let’s just say that. Structured in one place. And then making sure that it stays up to date, that it just doesn’t turn into say, “Oh, let me just move this version six of that data sheet over there,” and don’t look what needs to be cleaned up.
I think that’s the one. Look at your home, right? The more you organize things in your kitchen you know where things are, hopefully. But everything has a place, right? That makes y- it makes it faster, easier, more fun.
Carman Pirie: I think I’m going to need another analogy to fully understand your point. No I’m joking. This is I can’t… An organized kitchen isn’t something I can really wrap my head around.
Sannah Vinding: No, but I think the more you have that organized, the better you can have sales, customer service, right? Navigate within it. But if it’s just one mess, it is not easy. And then it just feels like you are, like it’s going uphill. So that one is the most important one and it doesn’t just saying, “Oh, we done it yesterday. We’re done,” right? This is continuous improvement and you need to… And that’s again, right? It goes back to the other pillars, right? You need to know who owns it. Who is it that approves it? So and it can sound boring and be like, “Oh my God, now we need an SOP for this,” right? But if you do that homework and structure it, you can scale, right?
You cannot scale if everything is just in one pile.
Jeff White: Man, that, that reminds me of another former guest that we had on the show Cynthia formerly of TE Connectivity, basically helped that organization create that data governance structure so that all of those documents were kept in the appropriate place and listed on the site in an intelligent information architecture, and there were managers for every division and part type and all of that.
That’s a challenge for a lot of manufacturers. It’s almost a role they don’t have now. How might you suggest that an organization that previously just, “If we got the document up on the web, that’s good enough,” migrate from that to a, a model where they’re truly thinking about having, a very clean data structure, not just for humans within the organization, but outside the organization and AI?
Sannah Vinding: But that’s a bigger picture, right? ’Cause that’s a whole strategy. It’s not just you saying in one team to say, “Oh, tomorrow we’re going to structure this.” It’s a company, it’s a strategy to say, “This is where we are today. This is where we wanna be. What does it take?” And then you can break it down.
I worked a couple of years ago with a product database that was non- existent, so we created the product database, imported where we had to get all the information for 114,000 SKUs, and then create all the parametric search of the values, right? Everything in so that could be specced out and pushed out to our website.
Creating the price book in there so that could go down to another file and speak to internal systems. It’s a, it’s much bigger. But again, if your company don’t have and saying, “Oh, we have the resources, we have the money,” right? “We will invest it,” and then this is a strategy.
You need to start smaller, and that’s also in my book. Create a little pilot, even if it’s just for a little category then to say, “Hey, let’s test this,” right? “Let’s have all this in this…” Maybe just start with that one folder then, and subfolders, and say, if it’s to sales, right? Or for FAE engineers to say, “Hey, we’re testing this out.
Can you see how it works?” And then you will get some feedback there, and saying, “Yeah maybe it’s good”. Maybe it’s like, “Oh, we’re missing that,” which is amazing if they’re saying something is missing because then you’re saying, “Oh, we should add that to, to to this folder,” right? So there’s different ways, but you don’t just start tomorrow and saying, “Oh, we are implementing.”
It has to be in the strategy.
Jeff White: I think that’s really good advice because otherwise this is probably so daunting that some manufacturers will just opt out.
Carman Pirie: Yeah, and it seems such a weird foundational thing to opt out of at the end of the day, because as Sannah mentioned, it powers so much, so that if you get that first pillar of the foundation wrong, the rest are all going to be pretty crumbly. And I guess I think I would’ve answered your question, Jeff, by saying I would encourage people if they’re trying to figure out what to do next is go back and listen to that episode from Cynthia, because it does two things. It’s not that it’s a step-by-step guide about how you ought to do it, but you see the complexity of it, and you ought to realize if you’re an adult with a brain listening to that episode, that to undertake this is not only of significant importance, but it’s going to be expensive, and it’s going to be something that we need to commit to at a reasonably senior level of the organization.
And it’s not a one and done as Sannah mentioned. I think, man, if you can get to that almost a bit like religion, if you can get to that level of belief, then we can deal with the rest of it, like the other parts will work out, yeah.
Sannah Vinding: Yeah.
Carman Pirie: Sannah I know we’ve bounced around a bit between the covers of the Visible or Invisible guide that you’re bringing to market here.
So I’m go- want to just… I wanna stop talking for a second and to end this show with you just giving us the 30-second elevator pitch about why somebody needs to pick up this book tomorrow or whenever it they can find it at a bookstore near them.
Sannah Vinding: So first you can go to visibleorinvisible.com and there you have the link to Amazon. It’s a Kindle and a paperback, so easy to buy. I think I just wanna say why I wrote it. I think that would be great to say, right? ’Cause I keep seeing small things, right? Good product in the organization I’ve been in where there was real engineering behind them, but they never made the shortlist because they’re just not visible.
So it’s not because they were not good enough, they just… buyers just couldn’t find them. So that’s why, with this book that AI is just doing so much more of the research and there is a gap right now that if you don’t jump on and create it and invest in it you’re going to be invisible.
So that’s why I wanted to give the companies here, a way to fix it.
Carman Pirie: Thank you for sharing it with us today. It’s been wonderful to have you on the show.
Sannah Vinding: Thank you so much.
Jeff White: Yes. Thanks again.
Featuring
Sannah Vinding
Author of Visible or Invisible
Sannah Vinding is a mechanical engineer and product management and product marketing leader in industrial B2B. Her work spans architectural and commercial lighting, hearing technology, electronic components and semiconductors, where she has led product and portfolio strategy, built marketing functions and led product information infrastructure across more than 100,000 SKUs. She is the author of Visible or Invisible: How Industrial B2B Companies Win Buyers When AI Builds the Shortlist, a #1 New Release in Industrial Marketing on Amazon, with a foreword by Walter Tobin, former CEO of ERA. She also produces and hosts the Leadership in Manufacturing podcast, with more than 150 episodes.
